Birkbeck Law Review
  • Home
  • About
    • Submissions
    • Join Us
  • Publications
    • Volume 6 Issue 1
    • Volume 5 Issue 1
    • Volume 4 Issue 1
    • Volume 3 Issue 2
    • Volume 3 Issue 1
    • Volume 2 Issue 2
    • Volume 2 Issue 1
    • Volume 1 Issue 2
    • Volume 1 Issue 1
  • Conference
    • 2017 Law and the City
    • 2015 Migration, Borders, Violence
    • 2014 Privacy and Surveillance
  • Blog
  • Contact

Volume 1 issue 2 October 2013

The Role of Morality in Cultural Defence Cases: Insights From a Dworkinian Analysis

James C Fisher
download pdf
Much academic and judicial energy continue to be expended over the role of culture in the law. The most contentious debate considers whether and to what extent a criminal defendant should be able to rely on his cultural background in his defence. This article draws on concepts from the fields of jurisprudence, socio-legal and cultural studies to identify and to probe the role of morality in this academic debate and in real-world judicial decisions. In doing so, this article analyses the ‘cultural defence’ debate in light of the revolutionary theory of adjudication promulgated by Professor Ronald Dworkin. Of all the competing jurisprudential theories, his arguably devotes the most attention to the importance of morality in adjudication.

The resulting analysis is then applied to a variety of prominent cases from various English-speaking legal jurisdictions in order to illuminate the hidden morality at work in judicial reasoning regarding the exculpatory power of a defendant’s culture. This reveals a hierarchical structure of interacting moral norms, indicating both a general enthusiasm for tolerance and widely varying moral responses to specific foreign cultural norms. By appreciating the mechanics of judicial reasoning in such cases, we can seek a principled and consistent response to invocations of the cultural defence.

Back

Site Map
Home
About
Submissions
Join Us
Blog
Publications
Events
Contact
Mailing Address
Birkbeck Law Review
14 Gower Street
London WC1E 6DP
United Kingdom


Contact Us:
admin@bbklr.org


Subscribe
Stay in touch with the latest news and information from the Birkbeck Law Review
Join our Mailing List
Copyright © 2012 - 2018 Birkbeck Law Review | A Publication of the Birkbeck Law Review Trust | (Print) ISSN 2052-1308 (Online) ISSN 2052-1316
All images, unless otherwise attributed, and the Birkbeck Law Review logo are © the Birkbeck Law Review and are NOT licensed under Creative Commons. All rights reserved.